As far as Sci-Fi goes this was a pretty good movie. As far as Star Trek goes, all I can do is facepalm. One might say that the movie has a great set of plot twists and all that. The CG space battles were excellent. But it was a silly Star Trek. Bridge too white, ship itself way too battle capable than it really should have been, plot twists as Star Trek goes were silly. Oh hey lets implode Vulcan. Ok!