Good: Edward, Carlisle, Esme, Emmett, Jasper, Charlie, Nomads, chemistry between Bella and Edward, conveyed general story
Bad: Bella, Alice, Rosalie, Forks High students, directing (over the top and campy), editing (choppy flow to the movie), special effects (although I give them a break. It was LOW budget), depth of the characters and story wasn't there, lack of music caused the mood to be off in alot of the film
As an indie or student film this would have been phenominal. But the movie got more publicity than they were expecting which brought expectations of a Hollywood blockbuster. I have high hopes that the sequels will get bigger budgets and be more on the mark.