I have seen this movie twice. I think it is an excellent movie. If you really liked the book, then this movie is for you. If you New Moon wasn't your favorite book, because Edward wasn't in it a lot, then you may not like the movie. Overall the directors and writers did a good job getting in all of the important details. Sure, some things were left out, but can you really take 400 or 500 page book and make into a 2 hour movie and get every last detail in??? Think about that before you rate the movie low.