I probably should't have read the book (for the 3rd time) right before the movie. Of course you can't have everything from the book in the movie!! Overall, this was better than the first two movies. However, I think there should have been a little more empasis put on the emotional struggle for Bella. And there wasn't enough Edward or his reactions! I did like Charlie and Jacob the best. They made the movie funny. The worst part about the movie, Victoria. What a disappointment. She was supposed to be cunning and leathal. This girl was like an actress on her first gig! Not a great fit for such an important role in the movie. But, I will go back! Can't wait to see the next one.