I am really disappointed to see so much critcism from the older Star Wars fans. They should remember how much they loved it as a kid. My son is 11, he is a huge Star Wars fanatic, and he loved the movie. He was able to fill in the gap with more details between the movies. The whole family really enjoyed the entire movie. The Battle Droids where hilarious. I thought it was perfect for the young fans and look forward to the TV series. PS Thanks George for the books for all ages too it has helped my son love to read.